{"version":1,"generatedAt":"2026-09-11T08:01:06.151Z","policy":{"localPathsExposed":false,"candidateIsVerifiedEvidence":false,"humanVerificationInferred":false},"items":[{"id":"PRV-2026-001","slug":"persistent-physical-symptoms-artifact","updated":"2026-08-13","title":{"ko":"지속성 신체 증상 핵심 문헌의 공개 저장소 원문","en":"Public repository artifact for a key persistent-physical-symptoms source"},"summary":{"ko":"네 서지 provider에서 식별한 2024년 Lancet 문헌을 White Rose 저장소 PDF와 연결하고 파일 signature와 hash를 고정했다.","en":"A 2024 Lancet source identified across four bibliographic providers and linked to a White Rose repository PDF with validated signature and fixed hash."},"query":{"text":"10.1016/S0140-6736(24)00623-8","locale":"en","runId":"RUN-20260812150128-C14CA52D","providerFailures":0},"source":{"sourceId":"SRC-6045A814656D9512","sourceType":"journal-article","identifiers":{"doi":"10.1016/s0140-6736(24)00623-8","pmid":"38879263","openalex":"W4399611661"},"providers":["Europe PMC","PubMed","OpenAlex","Crossref","Unpaywall"],"landingUrl":"https://doi.org/10.1016/s0140-6736(24)00623-8","status":"active"},"artifact":{"artifactId":"ART-195C76AF60671C4F","role":"repository-pdf","contentHash":"sha256:195c76af60671c4fc552cca4040638f04fe098d42df970d8f6a550a53148029f","byteLength":313191,"publicUrl":"https://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/id/eprint/213570/1/PIIS0140673624006238.pdf","verification":"PDF signature and structure validated"},"passage":null,"alerts":[],"gaps":[{"ko":"PDF passage locator와 인간 인용 검증은 아직 완료되지 않았다.","en":"PDF passage location and human citation verification are not yet complete."}]},{"id":"PRV-2026-002","slug":"zonzon-insomnia-passage","updated":"2026-08-13","title":{"ko":"『醫學衷中參西錄』 불면 의안 전사 passage","en":"Transcribed insomnia case passage from Yixue Zhongzhong Canxilu"},"summary":{"ko":"HanScope section을 실제 normalized artifact byte로 왕복 검증했다. 공개 웹 전사본이지 판본 이미지가 아니므로 witness 검증은 보류한다.","en":"A HanScope section round-tripped to exact bytes in a normalized artifact. It is a public-web transcription, not a facsimile witness, so witness verification remains withheld."},"query":{"text":"불면","locale":"ko","runId":"HS-20260812154742-E086EF69","providerFailures":0},"source":{"sourceId":"SRC-16788905689F440B","sourceType":"classical-witness-candidate","identifiers":{"hanscope":"km-theqi-oldbook-zonzon-chunk-02"},"providers":["HanScope section index"],"landingUrl":"https://theqi.com/cmed/oldbook/ZonZon/ZonZon5_12.html","status":"candidate"},"artifact":{"artifactId":"ART-76D0D13D83D8D801","role":"normalized-transcription","contentHash":"sha256:76d0d13d83d8d8015b060e491b4f01d2d9ae37c6c45b8cafd6bd0129018ef4b8","byteLength":622018,"publicUrl":null,"verification":"Local bytes verified; original witness not verified"},"passage":{"passageId":"PSG-3C7986E6DCD4FC31","layer":"normalized","section":"km-theqi-oldbook-zonzon-chunk-02::sec-064-01","byteStart":449910,"byteEnd":452348,"page":null,"imageOrCanvas":null,"textHash":"sha256:8122a08554efd3f3253f5eeb2a9064a32bd39d541659a85a295de9d9c8299826","excerpt":"醫學衷中參西錄 醫案 （十二）不寐病門","verification":"extracted","humanReviewed":false},"alerts":[],"gaps":[{"ko":"page/image locator가 없어 판본 passage로 승격할 수 없다.","en":"No page or image locator is available, so this cannot be promoted to a verified witness passage."},{"ko":"전문가의 문맥·판본·인용 적합성 검토 전이다.","en":"Expert review of context, edition, and citation fitness remains pending."}]},{"id":"PRV-2026-003","slug":"live-retraction-status","updated":"2026-08-13","title":{"ko":"실제 철회 문헌의 3-provider 상태 추적","en":"Three-provider status trace for a retracted publication"},"summary":{"ko":"PubMed, Europe PMC, Crossref가 같은 DOI의 철회를 독립적으로 표시했다. Crossref 정정·철회와 Europe PMC expression of concern 관계를 별도 alert로 보존한다.","en":"PubMed, Europe PMC, and Crossref independently flag the same DOI as retracted. Crossref corrections/retraction and the Europe PMC expression-of-concern relation remain separate alerts."},"query":{"text":"10.1016/S0140-6736(97)11096-0","locale":"en","runId":"MON-LIVE-20260813","providerFailures":0},"source":{"sourceId":"SRC-A1A327CA750B7668","sourceType":"journal-article","identifiers":{"doi":"10.1016/s0140-6736(97)11096-0","pmid":"9500320"},"providers":["PubMed","Europe PMC","Crossref"],"landingUrl":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9500320/","status":"retracted"},"artifact":null,"passage":null,"alerts":[{"type":"retraction","status":"unresolved","noticeDoi":"10.1016/s0140-6736(10)60175-4"},{"type":"correction","status":"unresolved","noticeDoi":"10.1016/s0140-6736(04)15715-2"},{"type":"expression-of-concern","status":"unresolved","noticeDoi":"10.1097/MEG.0b013e328349d184"}],"gaps":[{"ko":"이 상태 fixture는 감시기 검증용이며 연구 주제의 근거 묶음에 포함되지 않는다.","en":"This status fixture validates the monitor and is not part of the journal’s topical evidence bundle."}]},{"id":"PRV-2026-004","slug":"donguibogam-insomnia-facsimile-candidate","updated":"2026-08-13","title":{"ko":"『東醫寶鑒』 「虛煩不睡」 공개 영인 대조 후보","en":"Public-facsimile candidate for “Deficiency vexation with sleeplessness” in Donguibogam"},"summary":{"ko":"정규화 전사 후보를 공개 도메인 영인 PDF 17–18쪽과 기계적으로 고정하고, 11개 줄·2개 시각 후보의 내부 자대조 workbench를 준비했다. 파일과 후보 위치는 검증됐지만 전문가 자대조 전이므로 인용 근거가 아니다.","en":"A normalized transcription candidate is fixed to pages 17–18 of a public-domain facsimile, with an internal collation workbench for 11 lines and two visual hints. File identity and candidate location are verified, but it is not citation evidence before expert character-by-character adjudication."},"query":{"text":"不寐 · 不睡 · 虛煩不睡","locale":"zh-Hant","runId":"HSB-001-CORRECTED-V3","providerFailures":0},"source":{"sourceId":"SRC-DONGUI-NAEGYEONG-INSOMNIA","sourceType":"classical-facsimile-candidate","identifiers":{"commonsPageId":"127600630","shelfmark":"SSID-14233241","packet":"DNI-A72DE3D921CE4A8E","workbench":"CFWB-476F7A959EB67E7E"},"providers":["Wikimedia Commons public API","HanScope section index"],"landingUrl":"https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:SSID-14233241_%E6%9D%B1%E9%86%AB%E5%AF%B6%E9%91%91_%E5%85%A7%E6%99%AF%E7%AF%87_%E5%8D%B72.pdf","status":"candidate-pending-expert-review"},"artifact":{"artifactId":"ART-BD7CC2FEB8A81169","role":"public-domain-facsimile","contentHash":"sha256:bd7cc2feb8a811690e4120f7f6b5b3722115ccde241b4d7bbdd88282fb330b27","byteLength":25706234,"publicUrl":"https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:SSID-14233241_%E6%9D%B1%E9%86%AB%E5%AF%B6%E9%91%91_%E5%85%A7%E6%99%AF%E7%AF%87_%E5%8D%B72.pdf","verification":"PDF signature, repository SHA-1, local SHA-256, and official API metadata verified"},"passage":{"passageId":"PSG-D245A580E7F6A3C0","layer":"normalized","section":"內景篇二 · 夢 · 虛煩不睡 (candidate)","byteStart":659530,"byteEnd":661048,"page":"PDF 17–18 (printed folio pending)","imageOrCanvas":null,"textHash":"sha256:d245a580e7f6a3c08dceb04f2aa34e111c08141c2d93d2f005a0440f63963ef3","excerpt":"◎ 虛煩不睡 … 不寐有二種 …","verification":"candidate-aligned; expert character comparison pending","humanReviewed":false},"adjudication":{"adjudicationId":"ADJ-263B77AEB25D9BB9","decision":"pending","candidateIntegrityVerified":true,"humanReviewed":false,"promotionEligible":false,"acceptedGold":0,"reviewer":null,"reviewedAt":null},"alerts":[],"gaps":[{"ko":"전문가가 영인과 전사 글자를 자대조하고 편·권·문 및 인쇄 면수를 확인해야 한다.","en":"An expert must compare every character against the facsimile and confirm part, volume, division, and printed folio."},{"ko":"Accept 판정 전에는 주장 합성, 임상 추론 또는 gold corpus에 사용할 수 없다.","en":"Before an Accept decision, this candidate cannot enter claim synthesis, clinical inference, or the gold corpus."}]},{"id":"PRV-2026-005","slug":"medrxiv-versioned-jats-artifact","updated":"2026-08-13","title":{"ko":"medRxiv 다중 버전 JATS 원문 검증","en":"Versioned medRxiv JATS artifact verification"},"summary":{"ko":"동일 프리프린트의 두 버전을 bioRxiv/medRxiv API, Crossref, Europe PMC에서 병합하고 각 JATS XML의 파일 서명과 해시를 검증했다. 프리프린트는 동료심사 논문이 아니며 공개 파일 확인은 재배포 허가나 구절 근거 승격을 뜻하지 않는다.","en":"Two versions of one preprint were merged across the bioRxiv/medRxiv API, Crossref, and Europe PMC, then each JATS XML signature and hash was validated. A preprint is not peer-reviewed, and a public file does not establish redistribution permission or passage-level evidence."},"query":{"text":"10.1101/2020.09.09.20191205","locale":"en","runId":"PPR-20260812200134-229F694B","providerFailures":0},"source":{"sourceId":"SRC-5FD5E8334FBD2D29","sourceType":"preprint","identifiers":{"doi":"10.1101/2020.09.09.20191205","publishedDoi":"10.1038/s41467-021-21444-5","versions":"2"},"providers":["bioRxiv/medRxiv API","Crossref","Europe PMC"],"landingUrl":"https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.09.09.20191205v2","status":"preprint-artifact-verified"},"artifact":{"artifactId":"ART-0AFEF41342613126","role":"version-2-jats-candidate","contentHash":"sha256:0afef41342613126ecd05dac57e9eeaadb969cfd5ebe5e1f8cf7d159f4e82f5a","byteLength":118567,"publicUrl":"https://www.medrxiv.org/content/early/2020/09/11/2020.09.09.20191205.source.xml","verification":"Official-host response, XML signature, JATS article element, byte length, and SHA-256 validated"},"passage":null,"alerts":[],"gaps":[{"ko":"Crossref 출판 DOI 해소·제목/저자·역방향 관계를 대조했지만 최종 version-of-record 신원은 사람의 확인 전이다.","en":"Crossref target resolution, title/authors, and reverse relations were checked, but definitive version-of-record identity still awaits human confirmation."},{"ko":"라이선스 코드는 기록했지만 재배포 허가는 확인되지 않았고 인간 passage 검토도 0건이다.","en":"The license code is recorded, but redistribution permission is unverified and human passage review remains zero."}]},{"id":"PRV-2026-006","slug":"persistent-physical-symptoms-jats-passage","updated":"2026-08-13","title":{"ko":"지속성 신체 증상 프리프린트의 JATS 구절 원장","en":"JATS passage ledger for a persistent-physical-symptoms preprint"},"summary":{"ko":"비경계성 증상 연구와 직접 관련된 medRxiv 원문을 26개 section·51개 문단의 exact XML byte locator로 고정하고, 진단 경계·구성개념·인과 과잉해석·한계에 관한 6개 검토 질문을 만들었다. 모두 사람 판정 전 후보이며 근거나 치료 가설로 승격되지 않았다.","en":"A topical medRxiv source was fixed to exact XML byte locators across 26 sections and 51 paragraphs, with six review questions covering diagnostic boundaries, construct definition, causal overreach, and limitations. Every item remains pending human adjudication and has not been promoted to evidence or a treatment hypothesis."},"query":{"text":"persistent physical symptoms","locale":"en","runId":"PPR-20260812200109-CF801DF2","providerFailures":0},"source":{"sourceId":"SRC-C8CC91EA011D43CB","sourceType":"preprint","identifiers":{"doi":"10.1101/2024.07.29.24310991","publishedDoiCandidate":"10.1159/000551114","ledger":"PLG-9BC37BF1915FB712","reviewPacket":"PPRV-DD325CBA9460D079"},"providers":["bioRxiv/medRxiv API","Crossref","Europe PMC"],"landingUrl":"https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2024.07.29.24310991v1","status":"passage-candidates-pending-human-review"},"artifact":{"artifactId":"ART-06F65A52BB51BFE6","role":"version-1-jats-source","contentHash":"sha256:06f65a52bb51bfe6cdbb4eb1d5d791344ebcdbf7d4d6eb07adf5808e10522319","byteLength":166320,"publicUrl":"https://www.medrxiv.org/content/early/2024/07/29/2024.07.29.24310991.source.xml","verification":"Official-host response, XML/JATS structure, byte length, SHA-256, and 51 paragraph byte round-trips validated"},"passage":{"passageId":"PSG-28B54DFAE72B291A","layer":"source-text","section":"s1:Introduction","byteStart":18666,"byteEnd":20401,"page":null,"imageOrCanvas":null,"textHash":"sha256:c3b4a57b59c3ac9e31f50deb449d4ca85b614e290ea129af7db0b07a9ea275d1","excerpt":"Persistent physical symptoms … terminology fails to reflect the dynamic nature of medical knowledge …","verification":"exact raw XML byte round-trip; display text is a review derivative; human review pending","humanReviewed":false},"alerts":[],"gaps":[{"ko":"출판본은 PMC13145244로 식별됐지만 2026-09-05까지 embargo 상태다. 공개 뒤 최종 version identity와 문장 변화를 사람이 대조해야 한다.","en":"The published work is identified as PMC13145244 but remains under embargo until 2026-09-05. A human must compare definitive version identity and textual changes after public release."},{"ko":"유전적 공통 요인은 특정 한의학적 병리·처방·치료 효과를 검증하지 않는다.","en":"A shared genetic factor does not validate a particular Korean-medicine pathology, prescription, or treatment effect."}]}]}