{"version":1,"generatedAt":"2026-09-11T08:01:06.773Z","policy":{"publicationMeansValidated":false,"priorVersionsMayBeDeleted":false,"internalPreflightIsPeerReview":false},"allowedStates":["draft-private","preflight","awaiting-public-assessment","under-assessment","reviewed","validated","contested","corrected","superseded","withdrawn"],"packages":[{"schemaVersion":1,"packageId":"PRC-BRC-2026-P002","slug":"brc-2026-p002","targetWorkId":"BRC-2026-P002","targetSlug":"symptoms-beyond-diagnostic-boundaries-protocol","title":{"ko":"진단 경계 밖 증상 창립 프로토콜의 공개 평가 기록","en":"Public assessment record for the symptoms-beyond-diagnostic-boundaries protocol"},"state":"awaiting-public-assessment","externalReviewStatus":"not-started","versions":[{"version":"v0.1","status":"current","publishedAt":"2026-08-12","snapshotHash":"sha256:cf071857827e4010857999e5d04498b35ca9581e09d5935f7042e78139f88e66","changeSummary":{"ko":"최초 공개 프로토콜. 진단적 개방성과 적극적 증상 연구를 이중 트랙으로 명시했다.","en":"First public protocol, formalising diagnostic openness and active symptom research as dual tracks."}}],"assessments":[{"assessmentId":"ASM-2026-001","reviewType":"editorial-preflight","assessor":{"ko":"백록담 연구 방법론 게이트","en":"Baekrokdam research methods gate"},"assessorRole":{"ko":"내부 공개 전 점검 — 독립 동료심사 아님","en":"Internal pre-publication check — not independent peer review"},"independent":false,"conflictStatement":{"ko":"저자 조직과 같은 운영 주체다.","en":"Operated by the same organisation as the author group."},"publishedAt":"2026-08-12","dimensions":[{"dimension":"publication-readiness","rating":"pass","comment":{"ko":"문제, 안전 한계, 반증 가능성, 한·영 정합성이 공개 토론 가능한 형태다.","en":"Problem, safety boundaries, falsifiability, and bilingual alignment are structured for public discussion."}},{"dimension":"claim-support","rating":"not-assessed","comment":{"ko":"연구 결과가 아니라 프로토콜이며 과학적 타당성은 외부 심사 전이다.","en":"This is a protocol, not a result; scientific validity awaits external assessment."}},{"dimension":"source-fidelity","rating":"changes-required","comment":{"ko":"핵심 문장을 passage ledger에 연결하는 작업이 아직 완주되지 않았다.","en":"Substantive statements are not yet fully connected to the passage ledger."}},{"dimension":"clinical-safety","rating":"pass","comment":{"ko":"환자 선별도구·치료지침·자료수집 승인으로 오인되지 않도록 경계를 명시했다.","en":"Boundaries prevent interpretation as a screening tool, treatment guideline, or data-collection approval."}}]}],"responses":[{"responseId":"RSP-2026-001","assessmentId":"ASM-2026-001","author":{"ko":"백록담 리서치 커먼스 (BRC)","en":"Baekrokdam Research Commons (BRC)"},"publishedAt":"2026-08-13","status":"accepted","text":{"ko":"passage coverage가 완료되기 전 validated 또는 peer-reviewed로 표시하지 않고, provenance 공백을 공개한다.","en":"The protocol will not be labelled validated or peer reviewed before passage coverage is complete; provenance gaps remain public."}}],"unresolvedIssues":[{"issueId":"ISS-P002-001","status":"open","text":{"ko":"독립 임상의·방법론자·환자 관점의 외부 공개 평가가 0건이다.","en":"No independent public assessment from clinicians, methodologists, or patient perspectives has been completed."}},{"issueId":"ISS-P002-002","status":"open","text":{"ko":"필수 source universe와 claim-level passage coverage가 불완전하다.","en":"The required source universe and claim-level passage coverage remain incomplete."}}]},{"schemaVersion":1,"packageId":"PRC-BRC-2026-P001","slug":"brc-2026-p001","targetWorkId":"BRC-2026-P001","targetSlug":"allostasis-korean-medicine-revisited-protocol","title":{"ko":"알로스테시스 재검증 프로토콜의 공개 평가 기록","en":"Public assessment record for the allostasis reappraisal protocol"},"state":"awaiting-public-assessment","externalReviewStatus":"not-started","versions":[{"version":"v0.1","status":"current","publishedAt":"2026-08-12","snapshotHash":"sha256:f718c751e8ff5f0fd2ed6457df6f4fb3c1d394cf46fbd7dfbf8d365433d7a8fc","changeSummary":{"ko":"2012년 관점을 창간 중심 이론이 아닌 역사적 재검증 대상으로 제한한 최초 공개본.","en":"First public version restricting the 2012 thesis to historical reappraisal rather than a founding theory."}}],"assessments":[],"responses":[],"unresolvedIssues":[{"issueId":"ISS-P001-001","status":"open","text":{"ko":"외부 평가와 2012년 원문 claim ledger가 아직 없다.","en":"External assessment and the 2012 source claim ledger remain absent."}}]}]}